Israel Supreme Court weighs justice minister's power to pick investigation supervisors
Eleven justices gathered on Sunday to define the limits of ministerial authority in cases where senior prosecutors have conflicts of interest.
By Ananya Sharma ·

All eleven Supreme Court justices convened on Sunday to determine whether the justice minister can appoint an external supervisor for criminal investigations.
The hearing addresses a gap in Israeli law regarding who oversees a case when senior law enforcement officials cannot manage it due to conflicts of interest.
The dispute stems from a ruling issued last year that allowed Justice Minister Yariv Levin to select an outside monitor for the probe into former military advocate-general Yifat Tomer-Yerushalmi.
That investigation examined the leak of footage from the Sde Teiman detention facility and alleged obstruction in identifying those responsible.
Senior civilian law enforcement officials were barred from managing the case because they had reviewed the earlier examination of the leak and could be called as witnesses.
Supreme Court President Isaac Amit stated that the purpose of the expanded panel is to set precedential rules for future conflicts rather than to decide the specific supervisor for the Tomer-Yerushalmi investigation.
The legal fight centers on Section 23A(d) of the Civil Service Appointments Law, which permits a minister to assign another civil servant when the normally responsible official is blocked from handling a matter.
In a judgment dated November 16, 2025, the court allowed Levin to use this power but rejected his initial choice of judicial complaints commissioner Asher Kula because a law prohibits him from taking on other work.
The court also rejected the appointment of retired judge Joseph Ben-Hamo, citing that he did not meet the requirement of being a senior civil servant.
Attorney Yuval Yoaz, representing the Israel Democracy Guard, argued that supervisor selection should remain within the legal system to protect independence from political influence.
Yoaz told the court he would rule out a ministerial appointment under any circumstances, suggesting instead that an uninvolved deputy could make the selection.
Attorney Ran Rosenberg, representing the prosecution, countered that a ministerial appointment should be a last resort after a case-by-case examination of each official's involvement.', "He maintained that the entire institution should not be barred from handling a case based on a blanket finding of conflict.", "President Amit emphasized that the minister cannot personally decide who is barred from handling an investigation, while Justice Yael Willner noted that the prosecution was not arguing for a complete ban on such appointments.", "Justice Alex Stein stressed the need to interpret the law's provisions, and Deputy President Noam Sohlberg questioned where the law supported a restriction so sweeping that the minister could effectively never use the power.", "In the original proceedings, Levin argued that choosing a professional supervisor is distinct from directing the investigation and is necessary to protect public confidence.", "The justices discussed establishing an advance procedure for choosing a supervisor, with Justice Dafna Barak-Erez suggesting a formal framework and President Amit raising the possibility of selection by lottery.






