Charity Commission opens compliance case against UK mental health group after complaint
The regulator is gathering information from the Institute of Group Analysis regarding a political statement on its website, a move that has already led to a reduction in its board of trustees.
By Ama Ndlovu ·

The Charity Commission for England and Wales has opened a regulatory compliance case against the Institute of Group Analysis. The regulator confirmed the action earlier this month, following a formal complaint by UK Lawyers for Israel. The case concerns a political document hosted on the mental health charity's website.
A spokesperson for the Commission stated that the team is currently gathering information and speaking with the charity's trustees. The regulator emphasized that the investigation is in its initial stages and that no formal statutory inquiry has been opened. No findings of wrongdoing have been made at this point, and the Commission described the commencement of the case as a procedural step.
The dispute centers on a document titled 'Statement in Solidarity with Palestine.' Authored by Group Analysts for Palestine, the text was published using the Institute's branding without a disclaimer. First issued in December 2023 and updated in March, the document describes the authoring collective as formed in opposition to Zionism. It accuses Israel of committing genocide in effect and maintaining a system of apartheid since 1948.
UK Lawyers for Israel argued that the statement violated guidance on political activity. The group contended that such content must be factually accurate and connected to the charity's registered purpose of promoting mental health. In its referral, the legal group disputed the characterizations of genocide and apartheid. It also noted that the cited casualty figures of over 71,000 deaths originated from the Gaza Health Ministry rather than official Israeli sources.
The complaint warned that encouraging therapists to engage with the conflict clinically could create a hostile environment for Jewish members, trainees, and patients under the Equality Act 2010. After the Institute's trustees failed to respond to initial correspondence within 14 days, UK Lawyers for Israel referred the matter to the Commission in late September. A case manager confirmed to the group that the concerns warranted further regulatory engagement.
Internal changes have followed the dispute. The number of listed trustees on the Charity Commission register dropped from 13 in April to six in November. Correspondence reviewed by UK Lawyers for Israel indicates that five trustees resigned in connection with the statement, including Kate Taylor and Gayl McCain. Interim chair Graham Mackay acknowledged in a resignation letter that Jewish colleagues and students had experienced hurt and fear.
Mackay apologized for failures in communication and oversight, revealing that a sentence condemning Hamas's role in the October 7, 2023, atrocities had been omitted. He attributed his resignation to concerns over the board's functioning. Professor Stephen Frosh, a retired academic from Birkbeck, University of London, also stepped down and requested his name be removed from the website. The Institute did not respond to a request for comment by publication time.
More Business · World news · Business Watchdog · Report a business · Got a Story?






