Beef Industry Curriculum: Methane Lesson Removed After Rancher Pushback
A free science program used by 1.2 million students quietly dropped a unit on cattle methane emissions following complaints from producers, sparking debate over industry influence on classroom content.
By Ananya Sharma ·

The American Farm Bureau Foundation for Agriculture has quietly removed a lesson on cattle methane emissions from its free science curriculum after facing criticism from ranchers. The unit, titled "Methane & Cattle: A Climate Connection," was introduced late last year to more than 100 school districts and approximately 1.2 million students across the United States. It aimed to explain how cattle produce methane and the role that gas plays in environmental systems.
The removal followed online objections from industry figures who argued that blaming cows for climate change was unfair. Brett Kenzy, a South Dakota farmer and chair of a committee for R-CAL USA, called the lesson a "slap in the face." He stated that it was not fair to claim cows harm the environment because they are part of natural cycles. Rick Henningfeld, the foundation's education director, confirmed the decision at the CattleCon convention in February. He told attendees that the foundation heard the feedback and was editing the material with the hope of getting it back up quickly.
The lesson has not returned to the curriculum. A new unit on cattle digestion published in July makes no mention of methane or climate change. The foundation described the July update as "not a replacement" but rather a shorter topic that could not be covered in a standard 45-minute class. Officials said they are working on a longer version and reviewing research related to the biogenic cycle with the help of university experts.
The curriculum is funded by the beef checkoff, a mandatory levy on cattle sales. Program officials state that the goal is to eliminate negative perceptions of the industry among future consumers. Animal agriculture advocates often point to the biogenic cycle, where atmospheric methane breaks down into carbon dioxide within about 12 years and is reabsorbed by grass. They argue this process means cattle methane contributes little to global heating. However, mainstream climate researchers disagree with this assessment.
Carl-Friedrich Schleussner, a climate scientist at the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, noted that about 0.3 degrees Celsius of global warming to date is maintained by ongoing biogenic methane emissions. He said cutting these emissions is essential to slow global warming. Drew Shindell, a climate scientist at Duke University who chaired the UN's 2021 Global Methane Assessment, criticized the removal. He said it was a shame that ranchers would block students from learning about the world they will inherit. Shindell also pointed out an error in the withdrawn lesson, which stated livestock accounts for about 2% of human-caused methane emissions when the true figure is a little over 30%.
The backlash began with Jim Mundorf, a rancher and podcaster who criticized the lesson on his blog, Lonesome Lands. He wrote that blaming cattle for climate change was no different than blaming volcanoes or lightning strikes. His post was republished by the ranchers coalition of CPAC and amplified across the farming community. Henningfeld later confirmed the lesson was removed after feedback from farm bureau members and producers. The foundation said its review process invites producers to suggest topics and review draft materials.
Glenn Branch, deputy director of the National Center for Science Education, questioned the balance of power in this process. He asked what happens when producer goals conflict with scientific accuracy, suggesting the censorship implies producers' needs prevail. A study published in October by Jennifer Jacquet and Loredana Loy of the University of Miami found similar pressure tactics date back decades. Their archival research showed the National Cattlemen's Association treated global warming as a public relations problem in the 1980s and 1990s. In 1991, their pressure led Random House to end reprints of a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles book that linked cattle to global warming. In September, the US Department of Agriculture ordered agricultural checkoff programs to end support for environmental, social, and governance initiatives and net-zero targets.
The USDA stated it had no role in the specific removal of the methane lesson. The foundation continues to develop the curriculum with the support of the consultancy Vivayic, which is based in Nebraska. The organization said its goal is for students to make sense of real scientific data while accommodating the input of the industry that funds the program.
More Business · World news · Business Watchdog · Report a business · Got a Story?






